• Home
  • U.S. Supreme Court
    • US Supreme Court Briefs
  • News
    • Financial
    • Riviera Beach
    • North Bay Village
    • Palm Beach Sun
  • Videos
  • Gallery
  • Awards
    • The First Amendment Foundation Announces Winners of its 2017 Sunshine Awards
    • Four Time Winner – New Times Broward/Palm Beach “Best Of”
  • About Fane Lozman
  • Contact



I’m on a Boat! (Or Maybe I’m Not)

October 01, 2012
by Staff
Comments are off
Maritime law is as old as the republic, yet we continue to argue about what counts as a boat. The Supreme Court was home to that debate Monday as the justices heard arguments to decide if a Florida floating home was a vessel. Arguing yes was the city of Riviera Beach, which in 2009 used federal maritime law to have the structure “arrested” and towed away from a town marina. The city, which said the home violated marina safety regulations, later had it destroyed. The homeowner, Fane Lozman, cried foul, saying the city’s legal position stretched the definition of a vessel beyond the bounds of common sense. Mr. Lozman said the boxy two-story structure, which had French doors and no steering or motor, was a house in every sense, except that it floated. The quirky spat potentially has broad consequences: the vessel question can trigger the application of federal maritime law, which has special rules that can affect everything from worker-injury claims to property rights. The gambling industry in particular is following the case because it doesn’t want dockside casinos treated as vessels. We previewed the case in today’s WSJ. During an hourlong argument Monday morning, nearly every justice came armed with hypothetical questions designed to test the city’s argument that a vessel is any structure that is practically capable of moving people or things over water.
Chief Justice John Roberts: How about an inner tube or inflatable raft? Justice Elena Kagan: Tape some coins to the inner tube and now it’s moving money across the water – is it a vessel then?
Justice Stephen Breyer, meanwhile, asked about “Styrofoam sofas” (note to the justice: is there such a thing?) or other “absurd things that have nothing to do with ships or vessels and really could be used theoretically to carry something on the water.” Justice Anthony Kennedy was more concerned about real-life structures, such as the USS Intrepid, an aircraft carrier that was turned into a museum on the Hudson River. While the city’s lawyer, David Frederick of Kellogg, Huber, Hansen, Todd, Evans & Figel, appeared to have a difficult time defending his legal test of a vessel, Mr. Lozman’s arguments might not have sea legs, either. His lawyer, Stanford University law professor Jeffrey Fisher, said the vessel determination should depend on the purpose of the structure in question. Some justices suggested that a purpose-focused test wasn’t grounded in the language of the relevant federal statute. A decision is expected by the end of June. Wall Street Journal
About the Author
Social Share
  • google-share

Recent News

Make Riviera Beach buy my mostly submerged land
Fane Lozman to court: Make Riviera Beach buy my mostly submerged land
March 14, 2022 2:48 pm
fane lozman lake worth lagoon law suit
Lawsuit settlement lets Fane Lozman keep floating home in Intracoastal Waterway, at least for now
December 31, 2021 10:25 am
fane lozman lake worth lagoon law suit
Palm Beach County man being sued by Department of Justice
July 1, 2021 9:26 am
Fane Lozman wins supreme cort case
After 2 Supreme Court wins, Florida man gets $875K from city
February 12, 2020 8:07 pm

The Fane Lozman Story

Fane Lozman Activists - Supreme Court Case

This is a true story of a persistent and tenacious underdog who fought against the governmental seizure of 2200 homes and businesses in 2006 only to see that same government arrest and destroy his floating home three years later, for an alleged failure to pay one month’s rent at the marina. Fane Lozman did not give up but continued the improbable climb from a county court eviction case to the US Supreme Court.

Learn more.

Video of the Day

Honors and Awards

Voted not once, not twice, but three times as “Best Of” by the New Times Broward/Palm Beach.

  • 2012 Best Lawsuit- Fane Lozman vs. the City of Riviera Beach, Florida
  • 2007 – Best Political Activist
  • 2007 – Personal Best

Fane Lozman’s SCANSHIFT

SCANSHIFT™ is a revolutionary patented quote display system that allows the user to absorb market information and changing market conditions with a degree of mental and visual efficiency never before available.

Read more.

Copyright © 2018 to 2021 Fane Lozman.